National - Supreme Court opens door to in-person intervenors Skip to Content

Supreme Court opens door to in-person intervenors

Pilot project to launch in April where lawyers can seek to come to the court instead of appearing virtually

The Supreme Court of Canada crest
National Members

Log in to listen to this article

The Supreme Court of Canada will launch a pilot project this spring to allow more intervenors to appear in person.

In a notice to the profession released on Thursday morning, the Court said it had updated its guidance for intervenors. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Court had largely moved to having intervenors appear by video. That was intended to increase access to justice by reducing the costs involved in travelling to Ottawa to appear in person.

Under the new guidance, intervenors must seek permission from the Court to appear in person. If approved, they will get up to 10 minutes to present oral arguments to the Court. Intervenors appearing by video will still get five minutes to present their arguments to the Court.

An intervener seeking to appear in person must also provide an attestation certifying that they’ve advised their clients that doing so is optional and that all types of submissions are given equal consideration. As well, the Court has limited counsel for intervenors to one who may attend in person, though up to four names will be listed in the judgment.

In a statement, Canadian Bar Association President Loreley Chekay, K.C., welcomed the new guidance.

“We have raised concerns about limiting interveners to virtual participation, and we appreciate the Court’s openness to our members’ views,” she said, noting the option to request an in-person appearance allows counsel and their clients to weigh the benefits of engaging with the bench face-to-face against the costs and convenience of appearing virtually.

“Preserving the virtual option ensures that interveners with limited resources can continue to participate fully, which remains essential to access to justice. We look forward to working with the Court and sharing our members’ experience as the pilot unfolds.”

Eugene Meehan, a partner with Supreme Advocacy LLP in Ottawa and a frequent presenter at the Court, says the new guidance is a balanced approach that ensures intervenors’ time for oral submissions is earned rather than automatic, and that every submission, whether written or oral, still receives equal consideration.

“Of course, it remains to be seen how open the courthouse doors will be to make oral submissions in person, especially given the new requirement to explain why submissions ‘will be useful and will benefit the Court.’ But the Court has provided a helpful framework here,” he says.

Meehan, a former executive legal officer to former Chief Justice Lamer and former CBA president, says the Court’s rationale for denying in-person appearances was in the name of access to justice. In requiring counsel to obtain attestation from their clients, it may be continuing its cost-saving rationale.

Harini Sivalingam, director of the equality program at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, says her organization was the second-most heard intervenor at the Court over the past two years.

“The ability to appear in person is a really important element of advocacy, and being able to read body language, facial expressions, and the ability to look judges in the eyes is really important,” she says.

“There is a difference between how judges and people in the room perceive the arguments being made in-person in the courtroom and those appearing by video.”

Sivalingam says it’s more challenging for intervenors to have their points heard virtually, but it remains important to have the option, as appearing in person requires more resources.

She’s also concerned that the process for obtaining permission to appear in person imposes an additional burden on public-interest organizations, which are already trying to explain why their interventions are valuable to the Court. Now they’ll need to justify how oral submissions will benefit the Court.

Sivalingam is sympathetic to the concerns about too many intervenors in some cases, which can be taxing for the Court. She says there are opportunities for intervenor groups to work together to coordinate their efforts.

“There are ways to remove duplication with the regular leave process,” she says.

“We just hope that the Court’s pilot program will strengthen rather than restrict meaningful participation by public interest groups, and that the Court takes a robust approach to granting these requests.”