Navigating justice in the North
CBA-LCC journalism fellow Erik Pindera on what access to justice looks like in communities where road networks are sparse and some regions are fly-in only
Log in to listen to this article
When a community has no permanent lawyers, no judges, and no courthouses, what does access to justice look like?
That’s what journalist Erik Pindera, this year’s CBA-LCC journalism fellow, aimed to find out when he ventured to remote communities to report on Manitoba’s northern circuit courts.
Pindera’s been covering Manitoba’s justice system for years and knows the court beat well, but like many people from southern Canada, he had never seen the unique northern circuit court system in action.
His reporting has led to a four-part series, Northern Justice. It will run each week in the Winnipeg Free Press starting on November 21. His work will also be published in CBA National in the coming weeks.
The northern circuit court system brings judges, lawyers, and other legal experts to remote communities with limited legal resources. In a region where road networks are sparse, and some regions are fly-in only, it’s not surprising that one of the system’s biggest challenges is navigating the logistics of transporting legal professionals.
Pindera says typically a judge, defence lawyers, a Crown prosecutor, a victim services worker, and sometimes sheriff's officers all load onto a small jet, typically a 10-seater, and take to the air.
“Ideally (they) land in whatever community they're heading to in the next hour or so,” he tells Verdicts & Voices host Lisa Taylor.
That’s where obstacles can, and often do, arise.

“The communities where they're going to fly are hundreds of kilometres away and have typically relatively short gravel airstrips. So, they are particularly susceptible to changes in weather, and whether planes can land and take off or not,” he says.
Even if a plane manages to take off on time, problems can emerge in the air. Pindera experienced this first-hand on a trip to Little Grand Rapids First Nation in northeastern Manitoba last August.
While he was in the air with the circuit court team, the pilot turned to the judge and said there was an issue with the helicopter that was supposed to bring the team from the airport to the local community for the court proceedings. So, if the plane landed without extra transport arranged, the team would be stranded at the airport.
“The judge thankfully has been around a while and asked the pilot to contact the court's air circuit coordinator to contact the local RCMP detachment to ask them if they could do a favour and spare a couple of Mounties to boat over from the community proper to the airport, pick up the court party, and boat them back to the community,” Pindera says.
Things were up in the air for a bit, literally and figuratively, but 10 minutes later the pilot's dispatcher called back to say that the RCMP could do a favour.
So while court was able to go ahead that day, he says, “It’s pretty emblematic of the very complicated logistics of these circuit courts in particularly remote places.”
Another challenge with running a fly-in court is coordinating proceedings with flight schedules. Remote communities don’t have the luxury of multiple flight options each day or week, which can, in turn, limit the number of hours a court can be in session each day.
“In my experience going to a couple of circuit court sittings in remote places over the past few months, court really often won't start until 11 a.m. or noon,” Pindera says.
Because of air transport rules, the pilots will have to leave at a certain time, typically around 4:30 pm.
“So, depending on the community and distance between where court's being held, which is typically in some sort of community space — a community hall, recreational hall, band office, that sort of thing — you may have to be finished court by 3:30 pm.”
That only leaves a few hours to get through dozens of names on a docket.
Wraparound services like access to housing, addiction, and health supports are also rarer than in communities further south.
While he doesn’t want to paint all communities with the same brush, Pindera says that wraparound services that are tertiary to the justice system, like access to housing, as well as robust health, addiction, and mental health services and supports, are generally less available in the North.
For the most part, probation officers aren't coming into remote communities and running programming either.
“That's often left to essentially local restorative justice officials or officials from First Nations organizations to kind of fill that gap,” he says.
Pindera’s reporting also looks at the challenges of taking a system from southern Canada and trying to make it work in small, northern communities that are often Indigenous, and achieve justice for the people who live there.
“These communities are very different places with different cultural norms than much of the south,” he says.
“There are different ideas of how justice should look, how it should be performed, how involved the community should be in the justice process. That's less of a Western extractive form of justice in which someone does something wrong, it's prosecuted in a court of law, and they're removed from the community, and put in a jail or prison for X amount of time with conditions.”
Pindera says remote northern communities are increasingly looking at ways restorative programming can be a vehicle towards justice.
“Seeing how many people are going through restorative justice programming was eye-opening. You see a lot more of it on those dockets than you do on dockets down south, in my experience at least.”
Someone convicted of first-degree murder is not going to be sent to a restorative justice program, but the overall goal is to keep people out of the system long term.
“It's particularly for first-time offenders and more minor offenders to keep them out of the cycle of offending, to get them healthier, to get them and their families healthier, to get them involved in their community and trying to address their wrongdoing with the community in mind.”
Tune into the full episode to hear what Pindera thinks will happen now that circuit court cuts have been announced due to a shortage of judges, and what he wants readers across the country to understand about the realities of access to justice in northern Canada.
Pindera was able to undertake his reporting after being awarded the 2026 Law Commission of Canada and Canadian Bar Association Journalism Fellowship. Worth $40,000, it supports in-depth reporting projects that examine how the law affects people's lives. Applications for the 2027 fellowship are open until December 4.