“It is so hard to get to Canada right now.”
The shifting landscape of Canadian immigration law
Connectez-vous pour écouter l'article
Canada is a country of immigrants, but the rules and procedures of our immigration system are complex, ever-changing, and often poorly understood. In a context of shrinking federal targets, growing backlogs, and controversial new legislation, two immigration lawyers discuss how they and their clients are managing the uncertainty.
Christine Beltempo is an immigration lawyer at McCarthy Tetrault in Montreal and chair of the CBA’s Immigration Law Section. Cheryl Robinson is the Section’s vice-chair for refugee and litigation affairs; she works at Legal Aid Ontario’s Refugee Law Office in Toronto.
The host for this episode is Jessica Brando, a former CBC journalist and professor of journalism, radio and podcasting based in Ottawa.
Recent submissions from the CBA’s Immigration Law Section include:
- Bill C-12: consolidated comments
- Fixing the catch-22 of Canada’s business immigration programs
- Changes to asylum system risk adding delays, uncertainty
- Reforms to refugee rules could shift procedural burden onto vulnerable claimants
Verdicts & Voices is a legal current affairs podcast presented by the Canadian Bar Association. Views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the CBA.
Transcript
Welcome to Verdicts and Voices, a legal affairs podcast produced by the Canadian Bar Association. I'm Jessica Brando. I was a journalist at the CBC. I've taught journalism, radio, and podcasting, and I'll be behind the mic for a few episodes this fall. Canada has long been known as a country that welcomes immigrants, but for people hoping to build a life here, things are changing and they're changing quickly. Immigration targets have been reduced. New legislation is restricting access to refugee hearings. And thousands of legal challenges are making their way through an already overwhelmed federal court.
So, are these necessary changes to make the immigration system more manageable, or are they creating new barriers to fairness and access to justice? And what does all this mean for the lawyers helping people navigate the system? I've got two guests with me so we can explore the changing landscape of Canadian immigration law. Christine Beltempo is the chair of the Canadian Bar Association's National Immigration Law Section and an immigration lawyer in Montreal. And Cheryl Robinson is the section's vice chair for refugee and litigation affairs and an immigration clinic lawyer in Toronto. Welcome to you both.
Christine Beltempo
Thank you.
Cheryl Robinson
Thank you.
Jessica
So, Christine, let's start things out with: Imagine you're talking to somebody today who's wanting to immigrate to Canada. I'm wondering how different would your advice be from what it would have been 10 years ago?
Christine Beltempo
That's a great question. And I can actually share some personal thoughts on this because I sponsored my own husband 10 years ago. So I lived the immigration journey with him at that time. And obviously I advise clients today. So maybe the first thing is processing times. 10 years ago, my husband's entire permanent residence application took six months. Nowadays in Quebec, for an exactly similar application, it would probably take somewhere between three to five years. So I think that's actually a good example of how things have changed. The biggest changes have occurred since 2024, when the government really decided to do like a 360 change with regards to immigration generally.
There was a lot of reasons why that occurred, but what happened on the ground is that the government decided to reduce significantly the number of permanent residents they would allow into Canada each year. And throughout the 2015 to 2024 period, we had been moving towards a goal of reaching about 500,000 permanent residents per year. And in 2024, they decided to reduce that goal to about 380,000 permanent residents a year. So that's about a 25% reduction in numbers. And that had really, really significant impacts, both on the labour force, on our international commitments with regards to refugee applicants, and also with regards to family reunification and humanitarian and compassionate grounds applications. So it really had massive impacts throughout all the immigration pathways in Canada. So if I could summarize that in one word, the difference between 10 years ago and today, yes, there's delays, but it's also just an increase in how challenging it is to actually come to Canada and become a permanent resident, which actually means immigrating permanently to the country.
Jessica
So with the delays, it also sounds like there's more of an unpredictable side to things as well. And I'm wondering, Cheryl, can you tell me an example of how that shift is affecting clients that you might be working with?
Cheryl Robinson
So the clients I usually work with are more in the realm of refugees or persons without status. And I think the unpredictable nature is really related to the changes that have been made in terms of eligibility for refugee claims. For clients, it would be a combination of those that may have thought they would have ready access to a refugee claim, that, once they're able to come forward and explain what's happened to them, or the risk has arisen, they're able to access that refugee process. But the new changes have meant that, if your claim was made a year after you first arrived in Canada, you don't have access to that. And I think that level of unpredictability has spread a lot of fear because of the concerns, if I don't have access to refugee, what does that mean for my future when I can't return to my country of nationality?
And so I think, in terms of uncertainty, it also then falls on the counsel that are assisting, because it's very hard to come up with alternate options to a refugee claim, particularly because, as Christine said, processing times have become steadily longer, and in many cases we may have looked to the option of an application for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, but now we're seeing that those processing times are 10 years. And during that time, someone could be at risk of removal from Canada at any time. And so it's a very uncertain, very scary time for a lot of people coming forward. And that's particularly because if you don't have access to refugee, the alternate access is to a paper-based removal process, a risk assessment before removal. And it opens a lot of people up to difficulties in explaining their circumstances when they don't get to meet with someone in person. So it's definitely, I think, from top to bottom of the immigration and refugee system, there's just been a lot of changes that have created that uncertainty.
Jessica
Christine, we've seen Canada move from ambitious immigration targets, you mentioned, down from 500,000 now to closer to 380,000, along with some major changes to immigration legislation. From your perspective, what's driving this shift, and what are some of the current concerns that it raises for immigration lawyers?
Christine Beltempo
Absolutely. So when the shift really occurred in 2024, there was a lot of public outcry with regards to the numbers of immigrants that we were bringing into Canada, and not only permanent immigrants but also temporary residents. So that can be workers, that can be students, or even just visitors staying for long extended periods in Canada. And at the time, if you were following politics, there was a lot of talk about the housing crisis and this difficulty to make ends meet, between public services and just the number of new people arriving in Canada. So that's how the government explains that there was a need for a shift, whether that was right or wrong, I'm not one to say, but that's how they presented it to us.
Then obviously, following the election of Mark Carney, there was a number of policy measures and a number of operational guidelines that changed completely how immigration systems work. And what's particular about the immigration landscape is that not every change needs to pass through a legislative amendment, which means that there can be really, really quick changes that will affect people's daily lives, which is in fact what happened. So just an example is students who thought that they could easily renew their study permits or have a pathway towards permanent residence, well, suddenly that pathway was closed. Or people's spouses who were eligible for open work permits, which means that the spouses of a worker here in Canada could get a job and easily start contributing to the family household. Well, from one day to the next, they couldn't extend their work permits in Canada. So those are big changes that don't necessarily need legislative change. So what the government did is they did some changes that way, and they did other changes through legislative amendments, most notably through Bill C-12, which came into effect this year.
So we're seeing the government really take a lot of action through all the ways that it can to, in the government's words, quote unquote, control immigration or manage migration, which is how it's presented to the public. So it's definitely a big shift, and we continue to collaborate with the Canadian Bar Association to try to see how we can influence and make recommendations to bring back this predictability that you were talking about, because that is essential for applicants, just so that they can understand what the landscape is and what they need to be doing. Transparency, flexibility, and predictability is really what we've been advocating for in our meetings with government representatives, and I think that's where we need to continue our advocacy for the next year.
Jessica
In terms of the people who would like to become permanent residents because they're temporary residents right now, or permanent residents hoping to become citizens, how are those conversations that you're having with them evolving as the regulations and the rules, whether they're through legislation or strictly rules that could be passed outside of legislation, how are those conversations with these would-be Canadians evolving?
Christine Beltempo
Well, as a practitioner, you have to really set your expectations. I think the landscape changed a lot in the early part of 2025. I think now, at least our prime minister recently stated that he feels like immigration has been more managed, and we might be reopening some doors or finding new solutions. My interpretation of that is that they did a lot of very, very fast changes and now they're kind of realizing that they have to find the right balance between meeting the needs of the labour market and the economy, as well as maintaining reasonable amounts of new permanent and temporary residents in Canada. So when I speak to individuals or employers, I think it's just setting those expectations straight from the get-go, talking about processing times, talking about renewals, and really, really advising that people should have a long-term strategy to determine whether or not they're going to want to stay in Canada, because it takes a lot of reflection. And unfortunately, there is still a lot of uncertainty, even if you have a good strategic plan to get your permanent residence in the next couple of years. Obviously, everything is subject to change pretty quickly in this landscape. We do what we can, for sure.
Jessica
Sounds like those conversations are challenging, definitely. You both have referenced Bill C-12 and everything that has come since it was introduced. It's brought significant changes to Canada's asylum system. Can you explain what the legislation changes and why the CBA has raised concerns about it?
Cheryl Robinson
So there's quite a number of changes, but the main source of concern, I would say, is the new ineligibility provisions. So there are two groups that are now ineligible to be referred to the refugee board to have a hearing on their refugee claim. A group that, they want to bring forward their refugee claim more than a year after their first arrival. And I highlight “first arrival” because that wouldn't necessarily even mean the time that you came to Canada and wanted to make a refugee claim. It could mean that you came five years ago and that counts as your first arrival, and the timing is counted from that period.
And then the second group are those that are crossing along the Canada-US land border and not going through a port of entry, because they wouldn't meet the exception from the Safe Third Country Agreement, and then they make a claim after 14 days in Canada. Just to note that there was a previous bill that amended the legislation such that you couldn't actually make a claim in Canada within the first 14 days either. So it's effectively blocked off that pathway for those coming from the US between land borders. And so what that has done is it's shifted a significant number of people whose claims would have been referred to the refugee board, and who would have gotten a hearing on their refugee claim. And what it means is that a large group no longer get access to that hearing. Instead, they are redirected through something called a pre-removal risk assessment, which is a paper-based risk assessment process. They never meet with someone to explain their story. They never have someone to tell them, I don't understand this element of what you went through, can you explain it to me? So they never get an opportunity to really give the full information about what's happened to them and to be able to present that story and to have their refugee claim fully heard.
And that is the biggest source of concern for the CBA: that under a landmark hearing from the Supreme Court, Singh, a refugee hearing is a guarantee. That someone is there to listen to what your claim is and to assess the claim for credibility and for all elements of the refugee definition through that hearing process. And that this is a Charter-protected right that is available, that once you're here, to have that refugee claim be heard and to have that opportunity to have that full hearing. And this is the big source of our concern, that these individuals will have a lesser version of a refugee process, that they won't have that opportunity. And in fact, for some individuals who are from countries that have a suspension of removal, they won't even get that pre-removal risk assessment for many, many years. They will be here in limbo without any kind of assessment of their risk. And this leaves them at a distinct disadvantage and prevents them from having the refugee claim to which they should have access.
Jessica
So these windows of time where applications are admissible, by making them so tight, it's really restricting who might be able to access these claims.
Cheryl Robinson
Absolutely. And we can think of many circumstances where an individual who has a very meritorious and genuine refugee claim is not going to have access to the refugee process. Someone who has come from a situation of extreme trauma, for example, someone who's coming from a situation of domestic violence, who may actually upon entry to Canada still be in that relationship, and it has taken time for them to be able to come forward, to be able to speak to what their experiences are, or even to leave the partner that is in effect the agent of persecution. We can think about persons coming from extremely anti-LGBTQ countries who might not be able to speak about their sexual orientation or their gender identity upon first arrival to Canada, and it takes some time to come to grips with this and be able to speak to who they are. It doesn't mean that it's not meritorious. It just means that time is necessary for certain groups.
And we can see that as well, that risk arises in many forms, including changed country conditions. That doesn’t necessarily tie itself to when you first enter Canada. It arises at any time. And those individuals who have risk as a result of a civil war that's suddenly broken out, they no longer have access to this. And all of these groups, they need to be able to bring their risk forward to have someone hear and ask them questions, and they no longer get this opportunity. It is a breach of our responsibilities under the Refugee Convention. And it is not in line with our Charter, with cases such as Singh. And it raises a real concern, and it's also just, from a personal standpoint, really difficult speaking to claimants in these circumstances and telling them that they're no longer going to have access to a refugee hearing.
Jessica
Based on everything you've just said about the reasons why we could just call this unfair, this has spawned a whole slew of constitutional challenges before the Federal Court, and this is also something that the CBA warned would happen. Can we just briefly touch on what's at the heart of those challenges and how these cases could change Canada's refugee system?
Cheryl Robinson
So the cases right now that are in front of the Federal Court, they are challenging the ineligibility provisions. And so there's a number that are in what we call case management, and they're all being grouped together just because of the overwhelming number there would be for the court to consider. And the cases are coming forward basically on the challenge that these ineligibility provisions and the non-referral are not consistent with section 7 and section 15 of our Charter. And that's based on those elements that I mentioned before in terms of the requirement of access to that hearing. And then also for those persons from countries where there is a deferral, a suspension of removal, that they aren't going to have access in a meaningful time frame and that they are at a disadvantage and discriminated against as a result. So these cases are going forward. And the core outcome that the applicants are hoping for is to overturn those ineligibility provisions. So in essence, to restore access to the refugee board by getting rid of those ineligibilities.
Jessica
We're going to shift a little bit. I want to talk about public attitudes to immigration. Albertans, as you know, recently voted in favour of five immigration-related referendum proposals, including greater provincial control over immigration and restrictions on some services for temporary residents. But several of those votes were pretty close. So, Christine, when you look at those results, what do they tell you about the increasingly political place that immigration takes in Canada?
Christine Beltempo
Well, personally, I think immigration has always been politicized, whether in Canada or around the world. But I think what's happened in the relationship between the provinces and the federal government is the following. As I mentioned earlier, there were sweeping changes in 2024-2025, a reduction of the numbers of permanent residents that could settle in Canada. And one of the results of this was that each year, each province has a certain allocation of how many immigrants they can choose to reside in their province. And some provinces like Ontario and Alberta were really impacted by this, with reductions going up to 50%. So that means that in one given year, for example, if a province had, or was able to choose, about 50,000 people destined to live in their province, they had the authority to determine, who do we want, where do we want them to settle, what kind of professions do we need, what do we, as a province, need to help our province grow. And with that big reduction, I can tell you a lot of the provinces were pretty upset, right, because then their only reliance is on the federal government's programs, and they can't pick and choose anymore. So I think that's one of the reasons for the frustration and why some provinces want more autonomy, to be able to determine what kind of immigrants they want to better meet their needs and their ambitions. So I think that's one of the results that I've been seeing.
The second is there has been a lot of interest from the public with regards to immigration because it's been so mediatized. And whether that's good or bad, I think there was a lot of anti-immigrant sentiment in 2024, which is one of the reasons why I think some of the changes were put into place. And I think that's really unfortunate because that misses a lot of the question of why we ended up in a situation where there was what the government decided to be too many temporary residents or non-permanent residents in Canada. And I think it needs to be part of a bigger conversation to really look at how we can serve newcomers coming to Canada. And there's been a lot of reflection on this in the last two years. So I think in a way it's good that there's reflection. I think we have to be careful and we have to make sure that whatever is decided really affords newcomers a transparent and predictable system so that people can know what they're coming into.
And finally, Cheryl gave you an example, but there has to be flexibility built into the new systems that we're building, because without flexibility, we miss the mark, and people fall through the cracks, and it's unfortunate because those who fall through the cracks often tend to go underground and then that's not helpful at all for us trying to make the most of our immigration systems. I mean, if you look at the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, one of its goals is to increase not only the economic success of Canada but also the social and cultural fabric of the country. And I think we need to go back to those goals and make sure that we're aligned in what we prepare for the future.
Jessica
So maybe this is a good place to flow into the idea, what's one thing that you wish Canadians better understood about the immigration system? If we're going to leave off on that, what would be the message about, hey, this is what you should understand about it? Because I think probably some of what we're talking about today stems from a misunderstanding.
Christine Beltempo
Absolutely, and I think one thing I would say is it is so hard to get to Canada right now, whether as a temporary or as a permanent resident. Cheryl was talking about refugees. Refugees are such a small percentage of how many immigrants we accept into Canada. My grandparents were immigrants, and I like to think back on them a lot because they had no education, they had no language skills, they had, you know, basically nothing, and yet they came here and they fulfilled the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act's ambitions. They worked here, they created a family, their children went to school, and I think there really has to be more flexibility in the system, but I think right now you can't think that immigrants are just, we're opening the doors and we're allowing anybody to come into Canada. It is extremely controlled, extremely vetted. So I think it's important to give a chance to newcomers and to just treat them with respect, because they are our neighbours, they're our friends, they're our family members, and most of us are from immigrant backgrounds. So I think it's well worth getting interested in the subject before taking a position.
Cheryl Robinson
From my perspective, I would say that, as Christine said, refugees are a very small percentage, but one of the things I always find really interesting in conversation with others is this wild misunderstanding of what refugee actually is. So there's a perception out there that it's super easy to prove. You just have to say, I'm a refugee, and you make up a story and it's going to be granted. As someone who has worked in this field for the past 16 years, and this has been my main focus, it's not easy to prove that you are a refugee. It is not just a matter of a rubber stamp. You have to bring evidence, you have to be credible, you have to be able to explain why you can't get protection from your government, you can't go somewhere else. And these are actually quite difficult elements to prove. And the refugee definition is actually a lot more narrow than most people think it is.
So we have this perception, for example, that those from Ukraine that came here are all refugees. I hear this term thrown around all the time, the Ukrainian refugees. Well, a lot of those individuals are not refugees, not within the legal definition. And I think it's important to remember that who we think we're letting in as refugees may be a much smaller population. And when you actually are able to explain to someone why they need Canada's protection, I find most people are really responsive and are proud that we are extending that level of help and protection. And I would encourage individuals to really think about that, that we're doing this because we recognize ourselves as a country that wants to provide protection to others who are fleeing and need Canada's help. And that is a worthy goal for our immigration system and for us to support.
Jessica
I certainly appreciate both of you helping educate and set the record straight on all these questions. I'd like to thank our guests for sharing their perspectives on how Canada's changes to several pieces of immigration law are rewiring how they're practicing it. Christine Beltempo is chair of the Canadian Bar Association's National Immigration Law Section and an immigration lawyer in Montreal. Cheryl Robinson is vice chair for refugee and litigation affairs with the CBA's National Immigration Law Section, and she's an immigration clinic lawyer in Toronto. I very much appreciate both of you walking us through this very complex subject.
Christine Beltempo
Thank you.
Cheryl Robinson
Thank you.
Jessica
And thanks to you for listening. Verdicts & Voices is produced by the Canadian Bar Association. I'm Jessica Brando.