The Power of Perspectives

The Canadian Bar Association

Agnese Smith

Cover story

A basic right

By Agnese Smith June 27, 2016 27 June 2016

A basic right

Dismissed for years as a utopian thought experiment, the concept of a basic guaranteed income is now enjoying a renaissance as fears about automation and technological unemployment are on the rise.

The speed at which basic income has snowballed onto the public agenda has been astonishing. How to translate the idea into law is another matter altogether. If the past is any indication, decisions on welfare will likely remain a task for elected lawmakers. But could we see the day when the courts step in and rule that the Canadian Charter protects economic rights, even a basic income guarantee, as fundamental to human survival?

 “The very common response is that it’s beyond their jurisdiction. I don’t see that changing in the short-term,” said Margot Young, a professor in the Allard School of Law at the University of British Columbia, and expert in constitutional and social justice law. “Courts don’t take into account broad social changes overnight.”

For now, courts generally see the Charter’s main task as protecting individuals from state encroachment – described as negative rights – and not from destitution.

But popular opinion has been known to have an impact on judicial decision-making, as recent cases on assisted dying and the striking down of prostitution laws have shown.

Read More
Cover story

Artificial intelligence

By Agnese Smith September 11, 2015 11 September 2015

Artificial intelligence

In the world of artificial intelligence, one expert’s astonished gasp at a recent breakthrough is another’s ho-hum look of indifference. One academic’s fear that supercomputers could one day threaten civilization is another’s “meh.”

There is little consensus in the scientific community about how close we are to creating AI that exceeds or even approaches human intelligence, also known as “the technological singularity.” It could take 20 or 100 years — or it might never happen. And these debates would have remained in academic corridors had certain technology and scientific luminaries not issued dire warnings that AI might someday destroy humanity.

They include the world’s best-known cosmologist, Stephen Hawking, and Stuart Russell, co-author of the standard textbook on AI, and Silicon Valley titans Elon Musk of SpaceX and Skype co-founder Jaan Tallinn who have also tweeted and commented on the “existential risk” that emerging technologies may pose. The latter have given millions to think tanks and academic associations that explore this theme.

But how seriously should concerns about supercomputers and their intentions be taken? Many leaders in the field say there’s no need to panic — we are not even close to synthetically replicating the human brain. The immediate goal of policy makers, experts say, should be to understand how existing technology affects today’s society.

Read More
Article

Women on board(s)

By Agnese Smith December 16, 2014 16 December 2014

Women on board(s)

Read More
Article

The elephant in the room

By Agnese Smith April 29, 2014 29 April 2014

The elephant in the room

Read More
Article

Publish what you pay

By Agnese Smith June 12, 2013 12 June 2013

Publish what you pay

Read More

Currently doesn't have any blogs.

Current Issue

Editor's Picks

Editor's Picks

Editor's Picks