The Power of Perspectives

The Canadian Bar Association

Ann Macaulay

Ethics and criminal justice

Sexual assault trials: A failure of the legal profession?

By Ann Macaulay March 12, 2018 12 March 2018

Sexual assault trials: A failure of the legal profession?

 

The way sexual assault cases are practised and adjudicated by defence lawyers, prosecutors and judges regularly imposes unnecessary harms upon complainants, according to Dalhousie University law professor Elaine Craig. Players in each of these roles should play a part to prevent these harms and all have a duty to “uphold the law and those legal reforms that we have in place to protect complainants and the duty to intervene to prevent arguably unnecessarily aggressive, discriminatory or abusive cross-examinations,” she said.

Conclusions from Craig’s recent book, Putting Trials on Trial: Sexual Assault and the Failure of the Legal Profession, were central to the discussion of ethical challenges by a panel moderated by University of Calgary law professor Alice Woolley at a March CBA-FLSC Ethics Forum in Toronto.

Craig’s book examines ways the criminal trial process can be made less traumatic for sexual assault complainants without threatening or eroding the rights of the accused. She found that some criminal defenders ask improper questions, including prior sexual history. They “sometimes exploit rape myths that have been categorically rejected at law and sometimes unnecessarily harass and intimidate complainants in an effort to discourage them from continuing to willingly participate in the process.” These strategies are inconsistent with the law, she said, and judges have an ethical obligation “to make courtrooms as humane as possible under the circumstances,” including not forcing a complainant to testify while standing.

Read More
Complex litigation

The rise of high-stakes global class actions

By Ann Macaulay February 16, 2018 16 February 2018

The rise of high-stakes global class actions

 

Canadian lawyers face greater uncertainty as complex global class actions increase. At a February Ontario Bar Association Institute program, lawyers highlighted cases that have helped to evolve the landscape.

Cross-border class-action litigation has proliferated over the past five to 10 years, said panelist Nadia Campion of Polley Faith in Toronto. Plaintiffs are increasingly seeking to increase the size of their classes by including foreign class members, she said, adding that from about 2010, “the courts were not entirely comfortable with exercising jurisdiction over global classes. But that’s all changed now.”

Campion outlined two significant Court of Appeal decisions, both with many class claimants with no connections to Canada. Excalibur involved a Canadian auditor involved in a private placement of shares and warrants by American owners of a Chinese corporation. The Court of Appeal overruled the lower courts’ denial of certification, ruling that there was a real and substantial connection to Ontario, essentially saying that if class members “have been harmed or potentially harmed by operations of a Canadian entity operating in Canada, then that is sufficient to give rise to a real and substantial connection test under which jurisdiction can be exercised,” said Campion. The key consideration was that courts can exercise jurisdiction over claims against Ontario-based defendants.

Read More
The practice

The argument for hanging out your shingle on a professional corporation

By Ann Macaulay February 2, 2018 2 February 2018

The argument for hanging out your shingle on a professional corporation

Lawyers have several options when choosing their new firm’s business structure and should explore the pros and cons of each type before selecting the one that suits their needs best.

Options when setting up a firm include practising as a sole practitioner, establishing an association by sharing costs and resources, creating a virtual law firm, partnering with one or more other lawyers with the option of creating a limited liability practice, or even employing a combination of these structures.

All of these options have their own advantages: A sole proprietorship gives a lawyer complete control over the practice and all of its income and assets. A general partnership allows for a profit-sharing arrangement, in which each partner is jointly liable for the firm’s debts and obligations. An LLP provides the same tax benefits as a general partnership but limits the partners’ individual liability. An association between lawyers provides the opportunity to work together without a partnership agreement, offering services to a larger number of clients while sharing expenses.

Read More
Corporate criminal liability

Addressing corporate wrongdoing

By Ann Macaulay December 19, 2017 19 December 2017

Addressing corporate wrongdoing

 

The federal government’s plan to enhance the Integrity Regime for corporations, including the possible introduction of deferred prosecution agreements, is being welcomed by lawyers in the field.

The existing rules were designed to help the government conduct business with ethical companies and give suppliers an incentive to maintain strong ethical standards and effective compliance frameworks. A conviction can have disastrous results for a company that wants to do business with government.

Competition lawyer John Bodrug of Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP in Toronto says the proposed changes appear to be “a response to business and industry concerns about the very severe consequences for companies that rely heavily on government contracts, who are subjected to debarment under the Integrity Regime.” 

Read More
Practice hub- Lunch with

Stressed out? There’s help for that

By Ann Macaulay December 8, 2017 8 December 2017

Stressed out? There’s help for that

 

THE DINERS

The mentor: Doron Gold, Toronto psychotherapist and former family lawyer

The mentee: Madeleine Tyber, articling student with the Lawyers’ Professional Indemnity Company (LawPRO)

Madeleine Tyber is busy. She is articling with the Lawyers’ Professional Indemnity Company (LawPRO) and balancing her workload with family, hobbies and other personal commitments. Like many, she wonders how new lawyers can manage the stress of making it all work.

Across the table at Planta in Toronto’s Yorkville neighbourhood, Doron Gold, a Toronto psychotherapist and a former family lawyer, delivers some good news: there is plenty lawyers can do to protect their mental health. And there’s help available.

Read More